Review for lucy and linh by alice pung

December 19, 2016ReviewAsian-Australian, Chinese-Australian, Contemporary, Own Voices, Young AdultThe Shenners

Note: This book was originally published under the name Laurinda in australia back in 2014.

Bạn đang xem: Review for lucy and linh by alice pung

My Summary: Lucy Lam receives the Equal Access scholarship to lớn the prestigious Laurinda và walks into Year 10 thinking it will be her ticket out of the impoverished neighborhood her family lives in. While she is hopeful, she is also anxious about whether she will fit in among the elite students at her school. What she finds at Laurinda is equal parts fascinating & horrifying, and she must learn khổng lồ navigate the school’s social snakepit without losing sight of herself and her roots.


I was really looking forward to lớn reading this book, so much that I actually phối aside the #DiversityDecBingo book I was reading lớn read this instead. I can’t say I regret it.

A lot of books about diasporic Asians call out racism, but this book takes it to another level. I’d venture lớn say it offers one of the most incisive critiques of wealthy trắng people’s elitism và hypocrisy that I’ve seen in a young adult novel. I’m almost surprised that it managed khổng lồ get the green light for publication without some white publishing industry professional whining about “reverse racism,”

One of the refreshing things about this book is that it centers the experience of an Asian person from a working-class background. Lucy’s parents are not the educated elite that people often associate with diasporic Asians. She & her parents are refugees from Vietnam (her family is ethnically Chinese, though; Teochew, khổng lồ be specific). Her parents work long hours, her father at a carpet factory, her mother at home sewing knockoffs of thương hiệu clothes. They live in an area called Stanley, which others might hotline a “ghetto.” Given her background, Lucy is perfectly positioned to lớn see through and call out the pretentious bullshit of her classmates, their families, and her school.

At the beginning, Lucy is impressed by the glamour & glitz of Laurinda, but she quickly realizes how much of a sham it is. Although the school prides itself on its academic and extracurricular excellence, its most noteworthy trait, from Lucy’s perspective, is its expectation of conformity. Although the school administration and faculty play a part in this, the majority of this pressure is exerted by an elite group of girls called the Cabinet. The politics of the student body revolve around the whims of these three girls, and even the adults of the school are often at their mercy. One cannot cross them without the expectation that dire consequences will follow.

Although Lucy recognizes their influence and their ugliness, she eventually gets drawn into their orbit & becomes closer lớn them and their mothers. The proximity much more physical than it is emotional, & Lucy understands that their interest in her is anything but genuine. All the same, she puts up with their antics because she feels powerless lớn resist, knowing her future at Laurinda is on the line if she gets into trouble by breaking the mold. This nuance of nguồn dynamics is important because so often POC are roped into shit where walking away or fighting back will sabotage their hard-earned positions.

Xem thêm: Tag: Hot Girl Tho Dan - Phía Sau Những Bức Ảnh “Nóng” Hotgirl Thổ Dân

Against her better judgment, Lucy begins lớn internalize some of the toxicity of her environment. It’s gradual, but it creeps in. Thankfully, these views don’t go unchallenged. Lucy’s internal monologues & clapbacks are there for the reader, unpacking và eviscerating the wealthy trắng nonsense that the people around her spew. The racist and classist microaggressions, the blithe ignorance, the arrogant entitlement, the patronizing tokenism, the objectifying voyeurism, the white savior complex–all of these offenses are dragged through the mud in Lucy’s narration.

Which brings me lớn my next point. The book adopts an epistolary format. The story is told through a series of letters that Lucy writes to her former friend Linh, who attended her old Catholic school, Christ Our Savior, with her. This format allows Lucy lớn reminisce và discuss past events while linking them to lớn current events, highlighting the contrasts between Lucy’s old and new lives. It provides a humanizing insider’s perspective on the people & communities that are othered in Australian society and reveals the hypocrisy that the wealthy white elite consider themselves above the very people whose exploitation they depend upon for the image of superiority, the people who vày the honest work while they’re busy posturing over nothing.

Lucy’s parents provide contrasting perspectives on the wealthy trắng elite. Her mother is the relentlessly practical one who does things as necessary without much thought for appearances và status. Her father, on the other hand, is much more interested in looking good & more or less encourages Lucy lớn brown-nose & network khổng lồ her advantage. While she does succumb lớn pressure a little, she’s still resistant to lớn the principle, noting that her father doesn’t seem khổng lồ see the difference between exploitation and friendship. The Cabinet is very much about the former.

That all said, this book left some things to be desired. Although was some critique of how girls weaponize internalized misogyny against one another, the book doesn’t completely overturn misogynistic values. Lucy refers lớn a character as a “slutty virgin” (?) at some point, so the judgmental moralizing over women’s sexuality is an issue. Also, the book is a little bit gender essentialist in certain places, with the whole “men fight it out và get over it, women bitch & backstab and get petty revenge” thing.

As for queerness, well, let’s just say it’s only alluded khổng lồ but never really given full presence/development. Although Lucy refers lớn certain girls at her old school “discovering their true sexuality” after watching a play in which a girl stars as the main male protagonist, these characters are not named or given any more coverage. Overall, the book is pretty heteronormative in talking about romance & flirting. One character calls another a “lezzo” and while this person is portrayed as a distasteful character without a doubt, there isn’t really any direct narrative callout of her homophobia. Nor are there any explicitly named/described girls who like girls, despite the story taking place in an all girls school (like come on, statistically speaking, somebody there is gay/bi/pan). There are also no trans characters, but (sadly) this is practically a given in most YA novels.

Xem thêm: Hỏa Công Đầu Đà - Danh Sách Nhân Vật Trong Ỷ Thiên Đồ Long Ký

Recommendation: I’d recommend it for the hilariously snarky take on racism và classism but keep an eye out for the problematic stuff I mentioned.